Everything Wrong With The Golden Compass In 14 Minutes Or Less

The Pirate Nation
The Pirate Nation

This movie just felt like an atheist wanted to piss off anyone who believes in God. Not saying that I'm pissed off by the movie, just stating the vibe I got from watching this shit.

20 ore fa
Grisel Tellez
Grisel Tellez

Jenny and tai lung

Giorno fa
Bluena WOLF
Bluena WOLF

Lyra getting separated from Pan never happened in the book and thats why I have a huge problem with the movie but the effects are really good and fun to watch

5 giorni fa
Bluena WOLF
Bluena WOLF

READ THE BOOK. End of story

5 giorni fa
Twabbles
Twabbles

I saw the picture of the bear and I knew the entire story but I have never heard of this movie. This is weird af

7 giorni fa
Nick Hidalgo
Nick Hidalgo

Movie boring asf. 5 seconds in the video and i came to the comment section to type this then exit out of the video

7 giorni fa
Jade Cannon
Jade Cannon

...Am I going crazy?!?

7 giorni fa
Jade Cannon
Jade Cannon

Somewhere around 0:37 anyone see Bendy Boo Sempai!?

7 giorni fa
John Lemon
John Lemon

Voyager reference, (y)

8 giorni fa
James At
James At

I loved this movie! The majority of what you pointed out was not even part of the movie anyway.

9 giorni fa
fatdudewh33lchair
fatdudewh33lchair

This movie was confusing as fuck

9 giorni fa
Sun Razzers
Sun Razzers

Wario: But do you want to watch The Golden Compass with me! Waluigi: No, that movie is terrible Wario: Awww... I wonder who will get this reference

11 giorni fa
Catalyst Chris
Catalyst Chris

The book trilogy this movie is (tried to be) is literally my favourite three books and this movie (and kinda the video because of the movie) INFURIATED ME especially since everything that went unexplained WAS explained in the damn book In fact EVERY SIN wasn’t there in the books and don’t try to prove me wrong because I will call the flame war police What I’m trying to say is just the books are far more satisfying

11 giorni fa
flourescent adolescent
flourescent adolescent

Never read the book, thought the movie was good, different to anything else I'd seen for a while. Your negativity is not only ugly, but done badly.

12 giorni fa
eb060801
eb060801

"When someone is showing someone else how their... golden compass points" I found this funnier than I probably should have

13 giorni fa
hunter gatherer
hunter gatherer

Books were ok I read them in prison

14 giorni fa
jeroen willems
jeroen willems

Everything wrong with this yt clip Dude cant stop bitching about the smallest fantasy details... I thought i was gonna view some quality...

14 giorni fa
Joeyfield0
Joeyfield0

I like how I was looking at this video wondering if you'll point out things I missed, and while you do, you've hit everything else I've already thought about. 5:34 additional question: I thought daemons share thoughts, but are they different creatures or one in the same. I know the girl is smart enough to solve it, but did her companion speed that up? 5:47 I know in the book this makes more sense, but in the movie, don't the kids get way more benefits in living?

15 giorni fa
mycroft16
mycroft16

Points for the Spaceship Earth reference.

15 giorni fa
OK Howard
OK Howard

I’m starting to think that if every movie has sins, some sins must just be rules of filmmaking

16 giorni fa
OK Howard
OK Howard

Okay, maybe this made more sense in my head

16 giorni fa
Марко Зарић
Марко Зарић

Holly Sh...! This movie is bad!!! Just.....bad!

19 giorni fa
Meng Lü
Meng Lü

😀😎 𝙄 𝔀𝓸𝓾𝓵𝓭 𝚕𝚒𝚔𝚎 𝙩𝙤 𝚜𝚑𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝚖𝚎𝚝𝚑𝚘𝚍ddd 𝙩𝙝𝙖𝙩 𝙢𝙖𝙙𝙚 Miracless 𝙛𝙤𝙧 𝙢𝙚, 𝙮𝙤𝙪 𝙘𝙖𝙣 𝙨𝙚𝙚 𝙢𝙤𝙧𝙚 𝙖𝙗𝙤𝙪𝙩 𝙞𝙩 𝙞𝙣 𝓽𝓱𝓲𝓼 𝙫𝙞𝙙𝙚𝙤ooo 😀😎 >> https://bit.ly/2RIWKbp?ggR9PU_3MAg 😀😎 6171

21 giorno fa
Peaceful__ Inspiration_
Peaceful__ Inspiration_

2:20 there is a dude in the second row with huge fucking eyebrows, no sin for that?

22 giorni fa
Isaiah James
Isaiah James

Weird. I just realized I only beat the video game, never even watched the movie. And to think I was expecting an animated movie, like the game! 😂😂 damn. I played more games than watched tv as a child tho, so there's prolly a few movies I know the story to and remember, but never even watched

22 giorni fa
Carolyn Pitts
Carolyn Pitts

Wait a minute I have a question like I never really understood this how would you does the mother birth a daemon and their child that's kind of messed up and the thought of a human woman giving birth to an animal is kind of weird does she have to give two births or just one

24 giorni fa
Dawson Neddo
Dawson Neddo

This dude is really complaining about nothing

24 giorni fa
Bradley Dragon
Bradley Dragon

yea the "his dark materials" series. was an odd one. first book was utter stupid crap that explained little and was really dumb. subtle knife was AMAZING, and amber spyglass was good till the last couple chapters.. where it goes into some angel bullshit separating the girl and her boyfriend from a different world forever. EVEN THO THE ENTIRE FUCKIGN WORLD WAS RIDDLED WITH THOUSANDS OF SAID PORTALS AND SURVIVED JUST FINE. YOU CANT HAVE 2 PORTALS SO THEY CAN BE TOGETHER? LIKE CUT OUT THE CHRISTIAN BULLSHIT AND LEAVE ANGELS OUT OF YOUR STORY. #RANT. seriously tho the ending wanted me to burn the book. it was soo fucking bad. if it wasent a library book i would have set it on fire. not joking.

24 giorni fa
TommY WaffleZ
TommY WaffleZ

Didn't know Sam Elliot played Landon Ricketts in this movie

24 giorni fa
Adrian Benningfield
Adrian Benningfield

It is the polar bear necessity just the simple polar bear necessity

25 giorni fa
Adrian Benningfield
Adrian Benningfield

I was almost going to ask where is Tom Hanks then I remembered that was polar bear express 😁

25 giorni fa
James Priest
James Priest

Me feel dumb dumb sawing movie.

27 giorni fa
Lillian Michaelis
Lillian Michaelis

"at my pet turtle Theodosia" me: "dear Theodosia what to say to u? u have my eyes, u have ur mother's name and what u came into the world u cried and it broke my heart." yo Hamilton people, where u at?

28 giorni fa
The Infallible Avian
The Infallible Avian

RWBY did it better

29 giorni fa
very arigatoful
very arigatoful

the book series this film is based on is my second favourite series of all time! the film did NOT do philip pullman’s brilliant writing justice.

Mese fa
Edgy_12_year_old 1576
Edgy_12_year_old 1576

1. Dæmons are a spirit guide based on Greek spirits of the same name. 2. The movie is a very bad representation of the books. 3. If dæmons die their humans also die and vice versa. 4. It’s not brandy it’s 1886 tokay. (Correct me if I’m wrong about the date) 5. The monkey doesn’t speak in the book and it is rare that dæmons talk to other humans. They are one being. 6. This a garbage movie, the books are so much better.

Mese fa
KomodoComet
KomodoComet

So I'm not the only one who watched this movie?

Mese fa
Cats Terrace
Cats Terrace

3:30 its actually good form to do so but who cares add 10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 more sins

Mese fa
Celestial
Celestial

okay honestly? this adaptation fuckin BLEW and didn't do the book or anything it stood for any justice at all. but also? the fight between iorek and ragnar was SO graphic in the book. iorek LITERALLY TORE OUT RAGNAR'S HEART AND ATE IT BC TRADITION! it was so wild my little 11 yr old brain could not deal lmao anyways im just really waitin for the bbc one adaptation in 2019 bc that's bound to be better since its 1. not a movie and 2. bbc, not an americanized version of what is a very british story

Mese fa
Truelimits
Truelimits

I loved this movie so much when I was younger I miss it

Mese fa
CeraJeaux
CeraJeaux

I love your channel,, but this video is infuriating. The movie is based on a book, which came out BEFORE Harry Potter, so acting like it is trying to be HP is dumb. Most of your ?s are answered by the book. The movie failed b/c it didn't capture the spirit of the book. It got a good cast & CGI, but chopped off the ending, censoring everything interesting. It has nothing to do with HP! Why keep mentioning HP?! (I LOVE HP, but come on.) Hope the BBC/HBO series does a better job. & YOU.

Mese fa
h e l l o
h e l l o

this movie used to freak me out but I just kept watching it

Mese fa
Trench Cote
Trench Cote

When Sam Elliott points the revolver at the soldier, wouldn’t it go right through his cheek?

Mese fa
『Alt-F4』
『Alt-F4』

I really did like this movie when I first watched it over a decade ago, I really liked the new world that was introduced and I also thought Lyra was an interesting character (I was 10 ok?) but looking back on it now it really annoys me how much setup this movie did and the story had no resolution, plus there are SO many plot threads introduced so quickly, they could have made a TV series out of this. Maybe one day I'll get around to reading the books...

Mese fa
thomasfplm
thomasfplm

This movie is one of the movies that made me decide to nover see another movie based on a book I head.

Mese fa
thedogman142
thedogman142

My seventh grade class read this book and had to do a book report on it. I just watched the movie, unknowing that it was way different than the book. Fortunately, middle school doesn't count with the exception of the knowledge.

Mese fa
XxWingedMischiefxX
XxWingedMischiefxX

This film was so disappointing considering how good the books were.

Mese fa
Milligram
Milligram

The books are soooo good, though!

Mese fa
Gioiello Acula
Gioiello Acula

Those “golden snitches” were not originally from Harry Potter and Rowling didn’t come up with them first. They were first featured in Phantasm as giant spheres that flew around and sliced people.

Mese fa
aaishasmusic1963
aaishasmusic1963

I can't believe Nicole Kidman played a sinister character that helped kidnap kid's (right?) Especially because of the back story on her dad involving the rape and murder of children....I'm not judging her. I imagine she was abused too....I'm just sayin' because I am saying so.

Mese fa
aaishasmusic1963
aaishasmusic1963

What if it the kids deamon ends up being an elephant?  What's wrong with that? They won't eat people. They might chase or swash them

Mese fa
aaishasmusic1963
aaishasmusic1963

I just wanted to hear a review. The speaker is annoying as hell. I want another opinion in less than 1 and a half minutes of watching

Mese fa
RayTheGay
RayTheGay

This used to be my favorite movie. I would watch it at least once a week.

Mese fa
GoldBeam 12
GoldBeam 12

Ahh you live in Tennessee neat.

Mese fa
Erik Vince
Erik Vince

There could have been sequels the way it left off

Mese fa
Yali Perez
Yali Perez

I actually really like this movie. Is it dumb...yeah but I liked it. I think I have it in dvd still

Mese fa
Thomas Starbuck
Thomas Starbuck

This movie is almost completely different from the book

Mese fa
Soft-boiled
Soft-boiled

Camels, on wheels.

Mese fa
derf 213
derf 213

Good enough book but this is one of the movies I always bring up when talking about bad movie baced on a book

Mese fa
Li Skyfox
Li Skyfox

I actually liked the movie... I love the concept of the daemons, I liked the actor’s performances, the voice acting, and I loved the animation... I’ve never read the book, but I wish the movie got a sequel because lol that cliff hanger.

Mese fa
LunabugProductions
LunabugProductions

Li Skyfox You can get a sequel if you read the books ;) That said if you read the books you probably will like the movie less...

Mese fa
JR Stoelting
JR Stoelting

You should do Stardust as well. They came out at around the same time, but are vastly different

Mese fa
Constellationillustrations
Constellationillustrations

Here I thought I was crazy I thought this fell completely off the radar Id bring it up but my sisters never knew what I was talking about and I didn’t know the plot the only thing I could remember was the whole animal soul thing and I could remover the name for the life of me

Mese fa
Operative GP-5
Operative GP-5

5:15 *LAW & ORDER: SPECIAL VICTIMS UNIT*

Mese fa
Keith Richman
Keith Richman

IS THAT AAALLLLLLLL!!!!.....is that all

Mese fa
Rosslyne Samone Skinner
Rosslyne Samone Skinner

I didn't know this movie was as popular as it is.

Mese fa
Roderick Long
Roderick Long

The first Golden Compass book (to which this film is fairly faithful) came out two years before the first Harry Potter book. So any similarities between this and Harry Potter, if not coincidental, are cases of Harry Potter imitating The Golden Compass, NOT vice versa.

Mese fa
Pramit Dey
Pramit Dey

Read the books dumbass.Half of your questions will be answered there

Mese fa
Barry Mitchell
Barry Mitchell

The daemons come from the greek idea of demios that represents your ambitions and vocation. They thought that your calling in life was external to you. In the books, the daemon settling on a single form also is also interpreted by the church as a child becoming an adult and becoming subject to original sin. Phillip Pullman doesn't like fantasy for the sake of fantasy, he likes to draw use ideas that might have some familiarity with the audience. They completely messed this film up. It would have been better as a tv series without any flashy c.g. and more focus on character development.

Mese fa
dumplingshakes22
dumplingshakes22

I liked this movie haha

Mese fa
Scrumpton Mc.Laddy
Scrumpton Mc.Laddy

*Who else here thinks Daemons are just stands expect it's gone full animal*

Mese fa
Mashwiyat Rahman
Mashwiyat Rahman

This movie did negative justice to the book. In fact, they violated it in my opinion

Mese fa
boop the snoot
boop the snoot

yes, to be fair the CGI animals do look pretty good.

Mese fa
Ryan O'Neill
Ryan O'Neill

About dæmons shapshifting, notice how Pantalaimon can shapeshift almost freely with the only limit being Lyra’s imagination. A daemon loses this ability as their master matures, which is pretty much saying that adults are unimaginative. Not true, but they also shift into a form that best suits their master’s lifestyle and personality.

Mese fa
Benjamin Mark
Benjamin Mark

Next bond film bond and the leopards

2 mesi fa
Jacinda wolfy
Jacinda wolfy

*gasp* u didnt there is thothing wrong with this movie *watches video* I stand correct this movie is just......a movie Lol the cringe is real

2 mesi fa
Kenzzed
Kenzzed

I loved this movie and I was so sad when there were no sequels

2 mesi fa
Phillip Holmes
Phillip Holmes

Give some credit to the bloody lore before you butcher the film. The books were brought out several years ago and a lot of us anticipated the first film with glee and an actual understanding of what the fuck the into and peculiar aspects of the film actually mean. No disrespect intended but, do your research and appreciate the lore before to try to demolish a thing. I can appreciate hating on a thing that disassociates with the lore but the film makers genuinely tried making this a film for the hardcore fans as well as trying to appeal for a younger audience who don't know shit, as the books were aimed at teens afterall.

2 mesi fa
Faith Sizemore
Faith Sizemore

This was one of my favorite movie as a kid. *demons are the physical manifestations of a persons soul. ** this movie did fuck all for the actual book series which explains most of all this and is better. *** Yeah I’m gonna be that person. **** Also I fucking swear I remember their being a different ending where she goes to another world or some shit. Did I dream up an alternative ending. Wtf.

2 mesi fa
BaronSengir1008
BaronSengir1008

To be fair, the first book doesn't answer much either... Daemons are part of the humans' souls and take form depending upon their personality once they reach puberty... For example, all servants are dogs because dogs are known for loyalty...

2 mesi fa
Dana Chaya
Dana Chaya

when you can no longer watch a movie, tv show, or music video without hearing cinema sins in your head.... even if they haven't sinned that particular movie, tv show or music video lol. on another note, PLEASE SIN THE MOVIE "ONE FOR THE MONEY" AND THE FIRST EPISODE OF TEEN WOLF!!!

2 mesi fa
Crabby
Crabby

Could the narration BE more mind numbing?

2 mesi fa
Doololly2001
Doololly2001

The books were really good. If you really wanna know the answers to all the questions of what are daemons and what is dust and stuff, read the books. it's so fascinating and well-written. i highly recommend

2 mesi fa
GamerB0y13
GamerB0y13

I remember this movie. But does anyone remember the game?

2 mesi fa
Feno 3000
Feno 3000

Am I crazy for wanting to see the movies Cinemasins has made mockingly up MORE than this one? :D

2 mesi fa
Shining Me Precious Soul Of Mine
Shining Me Precious Soul Of Mine

All I remembered about this movie is my grandma didn’t let me watch it because it was somehow anti-Christian

2 mesi fa
Rais
Rais

In dire need of the sequel

2 mesi fa
Mariia the Hooman
Mariia the Hooman

Could you do the Darkest Minds?

2 mesi fa
Ao Tora
Ao Tora

Just imagine if you will... having a shark or a whale as a demon- now that would be impressive and weird.

2 mesi fa
David Heald
David Heald

Do Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory next, while you're still on book adaptations.

2 mesi fa
Robo Dragon
Robo Dragon

INCONCEIVABLE

2 mesi fa
E O
E O

*sees title* You fucker

2 mesi fa
E O
E O

Wait wait cinema-what-now? tigga, my tigga

2 mesi fa
Blobbert Mcblob
Blobbert Mcblob

This movie was decent....I think it was supposed to have gotten a sequel it never got.

2 mesi fa
Net_Spider
Net_Spider

"Wheres the freakin milk!" Been there with roommates....

2 mesi fa
TheSpacecraftX
TheSpacecraftX

British schools don't have hall passes.

2 mesi fa
Crystal Noe
Crystal Noe

Was so disappointed that all cinemasins could do was compare it to Harry Potter and pirate of the Caribbean when the book came out in 95 before all that other stuff. There were so many other sins to point out.

2 mesi fa
Caleb does stuff
Caleb does stuff

Where’s the milk where’s the freaking milk!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

2 mesi fa
This adventurous world of mine
This adventurous world of mine

Aaaaaaaand nobody knows how it's going to be continued, atleast in the trilogy which will never happen.

2 mesi fa
RhysHunterElkin
RhysHunterElkin

When I first saw this movie I really enjoyed it and was super disappointed that it didn't get a sequel. Then a few years later I got ahold of the books and realized exactly why the movie failed so hard and am very glad it didn't get any sequels. They should have gone full LotR on His Dark Materials (GC trilogy) and given us three 2h30m films to better adapt everything that happened in the books. I would love to see a proper adaptation of this, The Subtle Knife and The Amber Spyglass.

2 mesi fa
Nightfury
Nightfury

"I am Sinfrista Cinematigga, Clan-king of go f*ck yourself" I'm dying

2 mesi fa
CogitoErgoCogitoSum
CogitoErgoCogitoSum

There was a dumb movie a few decades ago where people went to war over something they called "spice".

2 mesi fa
Joel M
Joel M

5:18 Is pure gold

2 mesi fa

Prossimi video